Is There a Human Cost to Healthcare's Digital Transformation—And How to Find the Right Balance?
I learned about my cancer diagnosis through an email from a leading cancer center. This moment, following twelve consecutive core biopsies and a brutally negligent procedure, highlighted everything that is wrong with modern medicine. As a tech innovation veteran who has dedicated decades to championing human-centered design, I found myself not only battling cancer but also confronting a significant human divide. Despite the center's advanced clinical and technological resources, I faced medical errors, inadequate care, and a troubling lack of human empathy—experiences that left me feeling dehumanized, dismissed, and worried for both my life and the lives of other patients. This ordeal not only shattered my confidence in modern healthcare but also propelled me to reimagine a healthcare system where clinical excellence and human experience are purposefully integrated.
The Human-Technology Divide in Modern Medicine
The U.S. healthcare system commands an astounding $4.3 trillion annually (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2023). This investment has enabled remarkable breakthroughs in medical research, cutting-edge technologies, and innovative treatments. Yet, disturbingly, nearly half of patients hesitate to seek medical attention due to poor experiences navigating this same system (The Beryl Institute, 2021). This troubling pattern suggests that our technological and clinical advances have often come at the expense of the human experience—creating sophisticated treatments while neglecting the fundamental needs of those they're designed to heal.
Consider my experience with radiation therapy, a moment of deep vulnerability when I felt treated more like an item on an assembly line than a human being. While medical advancements offer incredible potential to improve outcomes, their implementation has fostered a system where human experiences are reduced to mechanical transactions. This dehumanization isn't simply an oversight; it reveals the priorities of modern medicine, which emphasizes scientific, operational, and technological achievements over human dignity.
Healthcare providers excel at analyzing clinical data; however, their overreliance on metrics, along with a lack of personal experience as seriously ill patients, limits their ability to fully understand patient care. While quantitative data plays a crucial role in clinical decision-making, it doesn’t capture the intricate realities of undergoing care as a vulnerable patient.
Current metrics often overlook the physical depletion, mental strain, and emotional challenges that patients face while navigating a poorly designed healthcare system. When healthcare providers make clinical decisions and design processes based on reductive metrics, they do so with a limited understanding of patient needs. This narrow understanding yields practices that drain patients. For marginalized populations, these issues are even more pronounced, further compromising health outcomes. Studies indicate that Black patients are 2.5 times more likely to experience adverse events during hospital stays (Institute for Healthcare Improvement, 2021), and LGBTQ+ individuals are twice as likely to avoid or delay medical care due to negative healthcare experiences (Center for American Progress, 2020).
The same disconnect pervades healthcare technologies. Throughout my cancer journey, I experienced how advanced diagnostic and treatment tools, despite their clinical promise, often create new layers of suffering for patients. Research confirms this reality: a 2023 study in the Journal of Patient Experience found that 74% of cancer patients reported that technological interventions increased their stress and anxiety levels. Life-saving treatments are often administered without fully considering their emotional and physical effects, reducing care to dehumanized and sometimes traumatizing interventions.
What should serve as tools for healing often become barriers to human connection. As a tech veteran, I know we can harness technologies to elevate—not diminish—humanity in healthcare.
Three Essential Shifts to Restore Humanity in Healthcare
This tech-human disconnect further deepens the divide between clinical excellence and the human experience. When systems prioritize technological advancement and operational efficiency over human dignity, they fail to provide patients with the care they need to heal as human beings. To effectively transform healthcare, we must align medical innovation with human needs. By valuing patients' lived experiences, we can create a healthcare system that is more humane, effective, and equitable.
The grant research I led at Emory School of Medicine, funded by Genentech, highlighted the potential for transformation in healthcare. By immersing providers in the realities of patients' journeys and empowering them to identify overlooked gaps in care, we can create pathways for more responsive and empathetic care. This approach is particularly important for marginalized populations, where the disconnect between provider understanding and patient experiences is most pronounced.
As both a patient and a researcher of healthcare experiences, I have closely observed how our advanced medical systems can undermine the individuals they are designed to support. Despite significant advancements in our technical capabilities, we have lost sight of what truly matters: the human elements of healing. Our technical advancements could save even more lives if paired with a deeper understanding of human experience.
The transformation we need requires more than superficial understanding. Here are three fundamental shifts that must occur:
Invest in Patient Experience Insights: Healthcare organizations should adopt strategies to gain a thorough understanding of biopsychosocial patient experiences. Current patient surveys capture only superficial feedback, missing the complex interplay of physical, psychological, and social dimensions of care. It's crucial to explore innovative methods to identify what patients truly experience.
Transform Healthcare Design: Patient experiences should drive the restructuring of healthcare delivery. By translating patient experience insights into actionable design principles, we can create systems that center human experiences over merely clinical efficiency—environments that uphold human dignity and improve health outcomes.
Humanize Medical Training: Medical education must evolve beyond traditional clinical expertise. While some curricula include communication skills training, these approaches often focus on procedural interactions rather than cultivating a deeper understanding of biopsychosocial patient experiences, resulting in disconnected clinical relationships. To promote genuine healing, healthcare providers need transformative training that integrates authentic human connection with technical skills.
The stakes could not be higher. Each day without meaningful transformation adds preventable suffering to a system that prioritizes efficiency over humanity. The human toll is devastating for everyone involved: patients lose trust, with studies showing that 44% of Americans have lost confidence in the system (Kaiser Family Foundation, 2023), while providers suffer too—over 50% report burnout symptoms (Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 2022), and one in five have left their positions since 2020 (CDC, 2022). These cascading effects—worsening health outcomes, deepening healthcare disparities, burned-out providers, and neglected patients—demonstrate that our current dehumanizing approach is unsustainable.
Yet, there is a clear path forward. Creating environments that genuinely prioritize the human experience in healthcare isn't just compassionate—it's effective. Research confirms this: Hospitals implementing human-centered design principles saw 26% higher patient satisfaction scores and 15% better clinical outcomes (Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 2022), while patient-centered communication interventions resulted in a 41% improvement in treatment adherence and 29% reduction in adverse events (JAMA, 2023).
Creating environments that genuinely prioritize the human experience in healthcare isn't just compassionate—it's effective.
The time for incremental changes has passed. We must pursue fundamental transformation before systemic failures claim more lives. No patient should ever struggle with dysfunctional care processes as I did. Healthcare's future must be both scientifically advanced and profoundly human—our lives depend on it.
If you found this article engaging, I’d love for you to like, comment, subscribe (it’s free), and share it with your network. As I embark on my journey with Substack, your support means the world to me. It motivates me to continue creating thought-provoking content. Every share is crucial in spreading these conversations and reaching a broader audience.
Sylvie your insights into the broken healthcare system and ways to fix it are excellent. It is really hard on the healthcare provider side with battling insurers for needed coverage, health systems for redundant processes as well as a complete shortage of staff and services. However as hard as it is on our end, it has to be so much more difficult as a patient. Many of us are trying to be part of the solution, rather than the problem. But it is not easy. Thank you for lighting the way.
Sylvie, Thank you so much for the thoughtful and concise commentary. I am glad you mentioned clinician burnout. In my experience, "burnout" is a major contributor to the lack of empathy and to medical errors. The three fundamental shifts that you proposed that must occur were provocative, although I believe changing medical education will be the most difficult. Please keep these insightful commentaries coming!